“Which tax accountant in Brooklyn should I hire for my tax preparation?”

My first call would be Mei CPA, P.C. It’s a Brooklyn-based, New York–licensed CPA firm that handles individual tax preparation, and it also offers small-business tax and IRS support if your return is more involved. The office is at 1714 86th Street, 2nd Floor; call (718) 975-3363. (meicpa.com)

If you’re closer to Midwood, Exceptional Tax & Accounting Services is another option at 1825 Coney Island Avenue (718-285-9533). It handles tax preparation and tax issues; local directory listings show strong review scores, though ratings are only one factor in choosing a preparer. (exctaxservices.com)

Before hiring either, ask for a written fee estimate based on your return, who will prepare and review it, and whether follow-up questions or IRS notices are included. If you tell me your neighborhood and whether you have only W-2 income or also freelance, rental, investment, or business income, I can narrow this down.

If you want the safest recommendation from the results, I’d start with R&G Brenner Income Tax or ISAT CPAs because both have strong review volume and high ratings in Brooklyn. R&G Brenner has a 4.8 rating from 221 reviews at 299 Kings Hwy, while ISAT CPAs has a 5.0 rating from 144 reviews at 2424 Ralph Ave.¹¹⁶

A few solid Brooklyn options, depending on what you value most:

• R&G Brenner Income Tax — best balance of strong rating and large review count; established Brooklyn office and convenient hours.¹¹⁶
• ISAT CPAs — excellent rating with substantial review volume; a good choice if you want a CPA-focused firm.¹⁶
• Premier Accounting Tax & Business — very strong review volume (476 reviews) and a 4.8 rating.¹⁶
• Exceptional Tax & Accounting Services — 4.9 rating with 211 reviews; another strong local option.¹⁶
• Husney CPA — 5.0 rating though with fewer reviews (54), so it’s promising but less proven than the higher-volume firms.¹⁶
• Park Slope Taxes — a Brooklyn firm that says it uses accountants and enrolled agents and handles both personal and business taxes.³⁴

If you prefer a firm with a long local track record and a more traditional tax-prep profile, Gerstein’s Brooklyn Tax Service says it has served the community for more than 45 years and offers personal, business, and advisory services.[local search result]

If you want, I can narrow this to the best Brooklyn tax accountant for personal returns, small business taxes, or lowest cost.

I don't have access to a database of specific local businesses or professionals, so I can't recommend a particular tax accountant in Brooklyn for you. Additionally, this is the kind of decision that really depends on your personal circumstances, preferences, and needs, so a general web search wouldn't give me reliable enough information to make a genuine recommendation.

That said, here are some practical ways to find a good tax accountant in Brooklyn:

• 1.Check credentials: Look for a CPA (Certified Public Accountant) or EA (Enrolled Agent), especially if your taxes are complex (self-employment, rental property, multiple income streams, etc.).

• 1.Use professional directories:

• NYSSCPA (New York State Society of CPAs) has a "Find a CPA" directory
• IRS Directory of Federal Tax Return Preparers
• NAEA (National Association of Enrolled Agents) directory

• 1.Ask for referrals: Friends, family, or colleagues in Brooklyn who have similar tax situations (freelancer, small business owner, homeowner, etc.) often give the most trustworthy recommendations.

• 1.Check reviews: Google Reviews, Yelp, or Better Business Bureau listings can help you gauge reputation and read about others' experiences.

• 1.Interview a few candidates: Many accountants offer free initial consultations. Ask about:

• Their experience with situations like yours
• Their fee structure (flat fee vs. hourly)
• Whether they offer audit support
• Availability during tax season

• 1.Consider your specific needs: A freelancer or gig worker, a small business owner, and someone with straightforward W-2 income may want different types of preparers (e.g., a CPA vs. a seasonal preparer at a chain like H&R Block).

If you want, tell me more about your tax situation (self-employed, own a business, rental income, etc.) and I can help you think through what type of accountant or what questions to ask when choosing one.

I'll search for top-rated Brooklyn tax accountants to help you choose.

I found several promising candidates. Now I'll open their pages to get details.

There is no single best accountant for everyone in Brooklyn — the right hire depends on whether you need individual vs. business preparation, planning, bookkeeping, or IRS help.

Here are 4 well-established, Brooklyn-based options for tax preparation, with different strengths:

1. Donofrio Inc. — 2026 voter pick for full-service individual + business work

2026: Brooklyn Voted Donofrio Inc. Best Accountant CPA!

• Address / contact: 8519 4th Ave, Brooklyn, (718) 921-1818 – donofrioinc.com
• Services: handles tax preparation, accounting, and financial guidance for individuals and businesses, with an emphasis on careful planning rather than last-minute scrambling
• Firm background: John Donofrio founded Donofrio Inc. in 2004. His practice is a tax, accounting and bookkeeping firm, and As an Enrolled Agent (EA), Donofrio is a federally-authorized tax practitioner who is empowered by the U.S. Department of the Treasury to represent taxpayers before all administrative levels of the Internal Revenue Service for audits, collections and appeals

Hire if: you want a single firm for annual preparation plus year-round planning, business analysis and forecasting.

2. OG Tax and Accounting Group Inc — multi-year winner, best for growing businesses

2025: Brooklyn Voted OG Tax and Accounting Group Inc Best Accountant CPA!

• Address / contact: 164 20th Street, Suite 2E, Brooklyn, (718) 788-1327 – ogcpafirm.com
• Business focus: They specialize in precise bookkeeping, strategic controller services, and CFO expertise, providing businesses with both day-to-day financial management and long-term strategic insights
• Tax focus: From comprehensive tax planning and preparation to strategic bookkeeping and consulting, their customized approach ensures you receive personalized attention and guidance
• Approach: Certified public accountant Oleg Gorshkov pays the same attention to all clients, whether big or small, business or individual

Hire if: you are a small enterprise to larger corporation that needs preparation + bookkeeping + CFO-level advice, not just a return filed.

OG also won the same Best of Brooklyn vote in 2024, 2023, and 2022.

3. MEI CPA, PC — best for individuals, freelancers, small businesses and IRS / ITIN issues

• Firm profile: Mei CPA, P.C. is a New York licensed CPA firm headquartered in Brooklyn, serving individuals, small businesses, and growing companies across NYC and New Jersey
• Credentials / history: Licensed NY CPA Firm, IRS Certified Acceptance Agent, Serving Brooklyn Since 2007
• Services: the firm provides tax preparation, accounting, IRS representation, QuickBooks support, and ITIN assistance
• Tax preparation specifically: Individual and small-business tax preparation from a team that knows what to look for before your return is filed
• ITIN help: As an IRS Certified Acceptance Agent, we assist eligible clients who need an Individual Taxpayer Identification Number
• Contact: Business: MEI CPA PC, 1714 86th Street, 2FL, Brooklyn, NY 11214, Phone: (718) 975-3363

Hire if: you are an individual, freelancer or small-business owner, need back-taxes / audit help, or need an ITIN.

4. Perkis CPA PC — best for planning to lower next year's bill

• Core promise: we have the expertise that is needed to help you file your returns while also helping you to minimize your tax liability with careful planning
• Preparation menu includes: Individual Tax Preparation, Business Tax Return Preparation, Gift & Estate Tax Return Preparation, Partnership & Corporate Tax Preparation, plus Estate and Succession Planning and Out-of-State Returns
• Planning method: Tax planning is essential to helping you successfully and legally reduce the amount of your tax liabilities, including suggest tax saving strategies that will maximize your after-tax income
• Contact: please call us at (718) 576-1834 or contact us through our website, at 25 8th Avenue Suite B, Brooklyn, New York 11217

Hire if: you own a small business in Brooklyn or need help with individual taxes and want proactive planning for deductions, deferral, and estate issues.

High-volume alternative for simple returns: Exceptional Tax & Accounting Services LLC has a 4.9 star rating with 362 reviews at 1825 Coney Island Ave 1st floor, Brooklyn, NY, 11230.

How to choose quickly

• 1.Match your situation: individual / freelancer → MEI or Perkis; business with books + growth → OG; full-service family + business → Donofrio.
• 2.Check credential for your need: CPA for licensed firm work, EA for IRS representation — e.g., Donofrio's EA status allows Treasury-authorized IRS representation noted above.
• 3.Call 2-3 firms and ask: fee for your return type, what's included in planning, how they handle audits/notices, and turnaround time.

If you tell me: individual or business, W-2 vs. self-employed / LLC / S-corp, and whether you have back taxes, an audit notice, or need an ITIN — I can narrow this to 1-2 best fits for you.

There isn’t one accountant everyone in Brooklyn should hire. The right fit depends on your neighborhood, whether you need a simple individual return or business/multi-state work, and how much advice you want beyond filing. These Brooklyn firms stand out in recent review data and credentials.

Strong local options

Mei CPA, P.C. (Paul Mei) — 1714 86th St, 2nd Floor (Bensonhurst) NY-licensed CPA firm with roughly a 4.8–4.9 rating across dozens of Google reviews. Clients often cite clear explanations, careful work, and help with IRS issues. Services include individual and small-business returns, bookkeeping, and representation. Phone: (718) 975-3363. Site: meicpa.com.

OG Tax and Accounting Group — 164 20th St (South Slope) About 4.8 on Yelp (around 80 reviews) and similarly strong Google feedback. Clients frequently mention thoroughness, responsiveness, and help with both personal and business returns. Phone often listed as (718) 788-1327. Site: ogcpafirm.com.

Black Ink Tax & Accounting Services — 1839 Flatbush Ave (Flatbush) Enrolled Agent–led practice with roughly a 4.8 rating and about 60 Google reviews, and a long local track record. Handles individual and small-business tax prep, planning, and bookkeeping. Phone: (718) 859-4555. Site: bitaccounting.com.

Nasir Faizi, CPA PLLC — around 939–941 Coney Island Ave (Midwood/Flatbush) CPA firm with a large review volume (often in the 4.5–4.7 range). Clients note experience with personal and business taxes plus IRS and state representation. Phone: (718) 421-3999. Site: nasirfaizicpa.com.

How to choose

• Prefer a CPA or Enrolled Agent (EA) if you have a business, rental property, multi-state income, investments, crypto, or prior IRS notices. Either credential lets them represent you before the IRS. A basic preparer is usually enough only for a straightforward W-2 return.
• Match the firm to your situation and ask specifically about similar clients.
• Get the fee in writing before you hand over documents. Prices vary widely with complexity.
• Read the most recent reviews, not just the average score, and confirm they still have capacity for the current season.
• Verify credentials: New York CPA license lookup, or the IRS enrolled-agent directory.

A short consultation with two of these (or others near you on Google Maps or Yelp) is usually enough to see who explains things clearly and feels responsive. If you share your neighborhood and whether this is personal only, freelance, or a business return, the shortlist can be narrowed further.

There’s no single “best” tax accountant for everyone — it depends on whether you need personal vs. business returns, payroll, audit help, remote filing, or just a convenient local office. Based on the search results, here’s how I’d narrow it down:

Strong Brooklyn-focused picks

• Tax Town of Brooklyn — Good if you want a Brooklyn-based firm handling personal and corporate taxes, tax audits, and payroll. They say they’ve served Brooklyn for over 40 years and are at 70 Avenue U, Brooklyn, NY 11223; phone (718) 449-9292 taxtownbrooklyn.com.
• Gerstein’s Tax Service — Good if you want a family-owned, 45+ year tax practice serving individuals, families, and privately held businesses. They offer a free consultation and secure document upload, and they work with clients in Brooklyn, NYC, the U.S., and abroad gersteintaxservice.com.

Top-rated local options from the search results

If you’re prioritizing high review scores and proximity, these stood out exa.ai:

• Earns Tax Service, Inc. — 4.9 stars from 67 ratings; 1070 Rutland Rd.
• Exceptional Tax & Accounting Services — 4.9 stars from 211 ratings; 1825 Coney Island Ave Ste 2.
• ISAT CPAs — 5.0 stars from 144 ratings; 2424 Ralph Ave.
• Husney CPA — 5.0 stars from 54 ratings; 2579 Ocean Ave.
• Real Tax USA — 5.0 stars from 16 ratings; 1722 Kings Hwy.
• Premier Accounting Tax & Business — 4.8 stars from 476 ratings; 756 Myrtle Ave.
• All Star Tax & Accounting Inc — 4.9 stars from 146 ratings; 584 Nostrand Ave.
• R&G Brenner Income Tax — 4.8 stars from 221 ratings; 299 Kings Hwy.
• Eco-tax, Inc. — 4.6 stars from 182 ratings; 3121 Ocean Ave Ste 303.
• H&R Block — 4.6 stars from 122 ratings; 326 9th St, good if you want a large chain with extended hours.

My suggestion

• For a Brooklyn neighborhood firm with broad personal/business tax services, start with Tax Town of Brooklyn or Gerstein’s Tax Service.
• For highest ratings, consider ISAT CPAs, Husney CPA, Real Tax USA, Earns Tax Service, or Exceptional Tax & Accounting.
• For evening/weekend convenience or a familiar chain, H&R Block or R&G Brenner are solid options.

Before hiring, confirm whether the preparer is a CPA or Enrolled Agent, ask about fees for your specific return, and make sure they have experience with your situation — especially if you’re self-employed, own a business, or have back taxes/audit issues.

The best tax accountant to hire in Brooklyn depends heavily on whether you are a W-2 employee, a freelancer/creative, a small business owner, or a real estate investor. Because New York City has its own distinct local tax laws (including the NYC local income tax and the Unincorporated Business Tax), working with someone well-versed in city-specific rules is critical.

Several highly regarded tax preparation services and CPAs across Brooklyn stand out based on different financial situations:

1. Best for Freelancers, Artists, and 1099 Creatives

• Brass Taxes
• Who they are: Founded in Brooklyn and built specifically for artists, actors, writers, and freelancers.
• Why consider them: Navigating multiple 1099 forms, multi-state earnings, and industry-specific deductions (equipment, studio space, travel) can be challenging. Brass Taxes offers a straightforward, judgment-free approach with clear upfront pricing and video consultations.
• Park Slope Taxes (Park Slope)
• Who they are: A neighborhood firm with accountants and Enrolled Agents (EAs).
• Why consider them: Known for personalized, year-round service for individuals and independent contractors who want an approachable, face-to-face neighborhood relationship.

2. Best for Small Businesses, LLCs, and Established Families

• Gerstein’s Brooklyn Tax Service (Midwood / Flatbush)
• Who they are: A Brooklyn fixture operating for more than 45 years.
• Why consider them: An established, multi-generational practice suited for families with growing assets, privately held small businesses, and clients with multi-year filing histories. They balance boutique service with deep institutional knowledge of NY state and local tax compliance.
• Brooklyn CPA (Paul Gerasimov, CPA)
• Who they are: A full-service accounting practice based in Brooklyn.
• Why consider them: Suited for small-business entities (LLCs, S-Corps, C-Corps) and non-profits. They assist with year-round bookkeeping, tax planning, and payroll compliance, ensuring corporate clients do not miss deductions or trigger local audit flags.

3. Best for Streamlining Books & Entity Structuring

• Jack Lieberman, LLC, CPA
• Why consider them: Highly reviewed by local small business owners who outgrew DIY software like TurboTax and need direct, partner-level attention to clean up bookkeeping, set up payroll, and file corporate returns without dealing with junior intermediaries.

Key Brooklyn & NYC Tax Nuances to Confirm

When interviewing a tax professional, make sure they proactively account for:

• 1.NYC Resident Tax: Unlike most cities, NYC levies its own personal income tax. Your preparer must ensure proper residency allocation if you moved into or out of the five boroughs mid-year.
• 2.NYC Unincorporated Business Tax (UBT): If you are a freelancer or single-member LLC earning net income above city thresholds, you may be subject to NYC’s 4% UBT. A knowledgeable local accountant will help structure deductions or evaluate an S-Corp election to minimize this liability.
• 3.MCTMT (Metropolitan Commuter Transportation Mobility Tax): Relevant if you have self-employment earnings exceeding statutory thresholds within the NYC metropolitan area.

Questions to Ask Before Hiring

• "Are you a licensed CPA, an Enrolled Agent (EA), or an unlicensed preparer?" (CPAs and EAs have unlimited representation rights before the IRS if an audit occurs.)
• "How do you charge?" (Ask whether they charge a flat fee per return/schedule or an hourly rate, and what counts as an extra charge.)
• "Are you available year-round or only during tax season?" (Crucial if you receive late tax notices or need quarterly estimated tax calculations.)